A new investigation has uncovered connections between private equity firms and the contentious development of a sprawling police and fire service training complex in Atlanta known as \u201cCop City\u201d and the police force which fatally shot an environmental activist.
Private equity refers to an opaque form of financing away from public markets in which funds and investors manage money for wealthy individuals and institutional investors such as university endowments and state employee pension funds.
Research shared exclusively with the Guardian details links between Roark Capital, an Atlanta-based private equity firm which owns the country\u2019s second-largest restaurant company, Inspire Brands, and a corporate backer of the Atlanta police foundation (APF).
Paul Brown, the CEO of Inspire Brands, whose portfolio includes fast-food franchises Dunkin\u2019, Baskin Robbins and Arby\u2019s, sits on the board of trustees of the APF, which is raising $60m from corporate funders to build Cop City in the Atlanta forest previously earmarked for a public park.
Police foundations are non-profits which raise private money from individual and corporate donors that is funnelled to police departments with little oversight or accountability. The APF has previously helped Atlanta police fund recruitment drives, surveillance cameras and Swat team equipment.
The police crackdown on community protests against Cop City have led to dozens of charges of domestic terrorism and the police killing of the environmental activist Manuel Paez Ter\u00e1n, known as \u201cTortuguita\u201d. Police said Paez Ter\u00e1n shot at them first, but have not produced any body-cam or other video footage of the shooting.
The APF has helped Atlanta become the most surveilled city in the US in large part thanks to a program called Operation Shield.
The Silicon Valley firm Silver Lake Management, one of the world\u2019s largest tech-focused private equity firms, has invested more than $1bn in Motorola Solutions, which designed and implemented the surveillance system for Operation Shield, according to a new report by the Private Equity Stakeholder Project (PESP).
Motorola has been criticised for providing hi-tech surveillance equipment used in US prisons, on the US-Mexico border and in the West Bank. Several European pension funds have divested from Motorola, and it was included in a UN list of companies \u201cthat had raised particular human rights concerns\u201d by providing surveillance tools and other services to the Israeli government.
Operation Shield currently boasts more than 12,800 private and public interconnected cameras monitored by the police \u2013 the highest number per capita in the country. Motorola has sold more than $22m worth of products and services to the Atlanta police department since 2016.
Silver Lake Management has invested money from pension funds paid into by Texas and Ohio teachers and South Dakota and California state employees, according to PitchBook.
In 2022, Silver Lake added Shadowbox Studios (formerly Blackhall Studios), a television and film studio company, to its portfolio with a $500m investment. The studios are located south of the Cop City site.
At an APF meeting on the Cop City budget in February, the agenda included what\u2002appeared to be a discussion on a possible future relationship between Shadowbox and the APF. The meeting agenda included the following item: \u201cAre there any scenarios where we can come up with some agreement to work with Shadowbox for them to help fund some components and in return they have access to use the facility for filming purposes?\u201d
There is no evidence that Shadowbox had any knowledge of the agenda item or that it has contributed in any way to the APF.
\u201cWe\u2019ve shown that private equity does have its hands in the controversy that is unfolding around Atlanta and its police force. Knowing the relationships Roark Capital and Silver Lake Management have with Cop City, [the Atlanta police department] and APF will give activists another tool to demand accountability for the recent violence and the destruction of the Georgia environment,\u201d said Amanda Mendoza, PESP researcher and co-author of the report.
The private equity industry manages about\u2002$11tn globally. Asset managers and funds buy and restructure companies including startups, franchises, troubled businesses and real estate operations using their clients\u2019 money. Yet unlike banks and other publicly listed companies, private equity firms are exempt from most financial disclosure rules, making it extremely difficult to track their assets \u2013 or risks.
It means people such as firefighters, nurses and teachers whose pensions are invested in private equity funds have little way of knowing if their retirement nest egg is financing police surveillance equipment, defence contractors, hospitals or coal plants.
The report Private Equity Profits from Destroying the Atlanta Forest is the latest attempt by researchers to uncloak the industry\u2019s activity.
Roark Capital mostly invests in franchises like fast-food chains and in February 2023 claimed $33bn in assets under management. The company has lobbied against a federal minimum wage, and a 2020 report by the Government Accountability Office found employees at some Roark brands were among the most frequent recipients of food stamps in some states.
After protests swept across the US in response to the 2020 police killing of George Floyd, Inspire Brands CEO and APF board member Paul Brown posted a letter on LinkedIn calling attention to \u201cviolence\u201d and \u201cattacks\u201d by protesters \u2013 without mentioning the police violence that triggered the protests. (Roark\u2019s own CEO donated thousands of dollars to the former Georgia senator David Perdue as he promoted the big lie and sought to overturn the 2020 presidential election.)
Another Roark connection is Marshall Freeman, who for seven years served as chief operating officer of the APF and sits on the board of the Inspire Brands Foundation, the company\u2019s philanthropic arm. Freeman has joined the Atlanta police department as a deputy chief administrative officer.
The enormous amounts of money at the disposal of private equity often comes from state employees and retirees
Charles Mahoney of California State University
Roark has invested money from several public worker pensions funds, including those of firefighters and police in Colorado, Los Angeles city employees, Oregon and New York state workers, and Louisiana teachers, according to PitchBook.
\u201cThe enormous amounts of money at the disposal of private equity often comes from state employees and retirees, who would be very surprised to learn where their investments are going. That\u2019s why it\u2019s important to follow the money,\u201d said Charles Mahoney, associate professor of political science at California State University who researches private equity investments in defence and national security.
Roark Capital did not respond to multiple requests for comment. Silver Lake declined to comment.
Atlanta is the US\u2019s 38th most populous city, according to the 2020 census. The APF, a non-profit whose corporate backers also include UPS, Home Depot, Wells Fargo and Coca Cola, is the second-largest police foundation in the country after New York City.
According to LittleSis, a corporate finance watchdog group, \u201cpolice foundations act as a backchannel for corporate and wealthy interests by funding policing even further, adding to already overinflated budgets without any required public oversight, approval, or accountability.\u201d
The Atlanta police department was allotted a third of the city\u2019s $700m budget in 2022, and has received additional money through the APF to expand its surveillance capacity and recruit more officers.
Less than a week after Atlanta police shot and killed Rayshard Brooks in the summer of 2020, the APF gave every officer in the city a $500 bonus.
The APF received a record $11.7m in donations in 2021, a figure likely to rise since Georgia passed new legislation expanding personal tax breaks last year. In addition to funding the police directly, the city has also given the APF more than $3.6m since 2016 for Swat team equipment, licence plate readers and thousands of cameras for Operation Shield.
Mendoza said: \u201cWhen it comes to policing, which already faces severe accountability and transparency issues, private equity involvement adds an additional layer of opaqueness. This report is just scratching the surface in investigating how private equity has contributed to not only moving these dangerous projects forward but also supporting a devolving situation of violence in the city.\u201d
Paez Ter\u00e1n was part of a broad social movement that opposes the $90m Cop City training complex planned for 85 acres of the South River forest, one of Atlanta\u2019s largest remaining green spaces. The social movement also opposes plans to develop 40 acres of public park in the same forest.
Paez Ter\u00e1n\u2019s death was the first known killing by police of an environmental activist in the US. The police crackdown has continued since his death amid growing local opposition to Cop City. Community concerns include increasing police militarization and excessive force especially against Black residents, as well as losing part of a forest that had been included in 2017 plans to create what would have been the city\u2019s largest park.<\/p>\n\n\n\n